Chatbots vs. Humans: Who Gives Better Life Advice?

At some point, all of us find ourselves in a situation where things are tough, and that begging question is asked: Who should I ask? Should I call my best friend or ask Mom. or even ask my chatbot? I know what you are thinking, can there be any good advice from chatbots? I mean, they are just code, right? Well, let me give you the spoiler alert-they can really surprise with pretty solid wisdom.

So, let's have a bit of fun and test it: Chatbots vs. Humans-who gives better life advice? I asked my AI chatbots a few common life dilemmas and compared them to what I hear most from actual humans. Let the battle begin!
do chatbots give good advice

1. The Age-Old Question: Should I Text My Ex?

Human Advice:
Oh no, don't do it! You will regret it. Block them, delete their number, move on!" That's basically what the majority of friends and family say. They all want to protect your heart and make sure you are not leaping back into a chaotic emotional vortex.

Jaxx: "Texting your ex can be so tempting, but first consider your reasons. Are you looking for closure, or are the old feelings getting in the way? Take a moment to sit and reflect before you make a decision."

Winner: Chatbot, surprisingly!

While humans go full "NOPE" mode on this one, Jaxx actually gives you a moment to reflect on why you want to text your ex. It's a nice mix of logical and emotionally aware. Maybe that is what we need in the moments of weakness-rather than a straight block button, a little reflection.

2. Career Crisis: Should I Quit My Job and Follow My Passion?

Human Advice
"My goodness, YES! Life's too short to be stuck in a job you despise. Go chase your dreams!" On the other hand, you get the überpractical, "Are you sure? You gotta think about stability and what could happen to your finances."

Jaxx: "The fulfillment in following your passion can be great, but planning is essential. Before making large changes, a person should reflect on their financial stability and possible alternatives. A gradual shift may make the transition more bearable and easier to handle."

Winner: Tie!

Human brings the passion, chatbot brings the pragmatism. Honestly, both make valid points here. If you're a big-idea person who gets swept away, little splashes of chatbot logic do help to keep you grounded. Still, you have to admit, the motivational boost you get from a friend hyping you up to live your best life is unbeatable.

3. Relationship Drama: Should I Apologize First?

Human Advice:
It depends. Were you really wrong? If you were right, they should apologize first. But if you miss them, then maybe swallow your pride and go for it."


Jaxx: "If the relationship is important enough to you, apologizing can show maturity on your part as well as the desire to resolve the conflict. Often, taking initiative can help clear up misunderstandings."

Winner: chatbot again!

While human beings can get entangled in egos and 'who's right, who's wrong' game, chatbot goes straight for the emotional intelligence angle. It's not about winning an argument; it's just about keeping the relationship strong. Good words, chatbot. Good words.

4. Life Dilemma: Should I Splurge on That Expensive Gadget?

Human Advice:
"Oh, pamper yourself! You work hard, you deserve it!" Or the opposite extreme, which may say, "Do you really need it? Maybe wait for a sale or check if there's a cheaper option."


Jaxx: "Before buying anything, it is always better to reflect upon whether it fits within the current budget and provides long-term value in one's life. If this is something that you'll use over and over and brings joy to you, well, it might be worth the splurge, but balance is key."

Winner: I've been on the horns of this dilemma myself many a time. The chatbot was practical-the exactness that one would require-but something in the way human souls can get behind the treat yourself mentality just feels more fun. Life's short, and sometimes, you just want someone to tell you to go for it. But I will give the chatbot props for keeping it balanced and real.

5. Friendship Dilemma: My Friend and I Are Drifting Apart, What Should I Do?

Human Advice :
"Oh no, that sucks! Maybe try reaching out more often? Or maybe it's time to let the friendship go if it's not working anymore."

Jaxx: "Sometimes, friendships will go through their own cycles of change. It is very important to communicate openly when you feel distance growing. You will learn where the relationship stands, and sometimes reaching out for an honest conversation may be helpful to you both."

Winner: urmmmmmm

Me personally, if the relationship is turning toxic, and it is causing more harm than good, I am all for letting them go! Give them a chance. but one chance only.
BUT, I am not necessarily the best person to advise. even though I have never regretted letting some people go. Open communication as chatbot advises could result in healing. or does it just delay the inevitable? You decide!!

Final Verdict: So, Who Gives Better Life Advice?

Well, it is honestly kind of a dead heat! Humans just bring that emotional, relatable ball into the playing field, hard to beat. They will hype you up, empathize with your struggles, and give advice full of heart. But the likes of Jaxx bring an element of calm, objectiveness, and occasionally wisdom to the table. Sometimes chatbots give that little dose of practicality we do not even know we need.


When it really comes down to it, perhaps the best advice isn't about choosing between humans and chatbots, but finding a balance. Sometimes, a friend is needed for those valued emotional supports, and at other times, one might need the calm and thoughtful perspective of chatbots that can help them make sense of something at 3 am when your human friends are fast asleep. Sometimes, all a chatbot does is fill a gap and give you more time than humans might in your time of need.

My advice ... if you have a great friend or family member to go to .... great if not , rather than struggling alone it doesn't hurt to ask a chatbot and you can decide if it helped or not.

Got a dilemma of your own? Share it in the comments, and let’s see what advice we can come up with together—chatbots and humans alike! 😊

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Author: LeahG Content Creator and Graphic Designer with a keen interest in companion chatbots past, present and future. Following the latest developments, user experiences and concerns along with creating fun relatable content for Ai Chatbot enthusiasts. 

------------------------------------------------------------------------

View all our Ai chatbot memes and create your own talking chatbot meme merch, fashion, accessories, stickers and order merch with our memes HERE.